Mark2jz
Anthony hernandez
@Mark2jz · 2 days ago

Either i have bad luck with hammer coral or something is wrong with my tank cause I cant keep them from staying closed up. This is my first hammer that has died and the one that is on the rock seems to loose heads. Also would there be a reason for my star polyp to not open?

4 photos
15

Comments

Sign in to leave a comment

User Avatar @Snappy_Beetle_75 2d

ugh that sucks hope it tyourns around

User Avatar @Mark2jz 2d

Thank you!!

User Avatar @AJN771 2d

Can you upload a video so we can see the flow

User Avatar @Mark2jz 2d

Yeah no problem! Ill finish up work and take a video as soon as get home.

User Avatar @ReefKC 2d
comment image

I have had a lot more success with my hammers keeping mag 1400-1500 and dosing AF Life Source 1 scoop a week they have all really puffed up more and seem to be starting to split more.

User Avatar @708_reef 2d

Hammers love high mag

User Avatar @Mark2jz 2d

Wow! That looks amazing!! I'm hoping to get to that point

User Avatar @newbee 2d

Phosphates too high Not enough light

User Avatar @Mark2jz 2d

Ill check it one more time today to see where its at today.

User Avatar @carpetsurfer 2d

I have 4 varieties of hammers all thriving at various light levels 50-150PAR so here's my advice: around 1400 mag, 400-500 calc (mine is 600 right now for some reason), 1.025sg, 5-15 nitrates, up to .1 phosphates, 78f. Those are the things I find are easy to control with regular water changes, don't chase the other numbers. I do weekly 15% water changes to replenish trace elements using redsea coral pro salt. I don't do anything else except clean the filter sock and skimmer cup. Mine are all happy in relatively low flow, polyps barely swaying around. Good luck!

User Avatar @Mark2jz 2d

Thank you soooo much for your help!! And info! Ill definitely keep that in mind now! I hope i can have a hammer garden soon 😁

User Avatar @carpetsurfer 2d

I'm by no means an expert, do your water changes and don't stress too much! How old is your tank by the way? Edit: the only things I really control are temp, salinity, phosphate and nitrate. The salt mix I use keeps everything else very stable (if my first response wasn't clear)

User Avatar @Mark2jz 2d

It's about two 3 months old now, right now my phosphate are at .16 so ill probably do a 15% water change

User Avatar @carpetsurfer 1d

Yeah that's a little high, mines high too right now, but I promise the small weekly changes will probably solve a lot 🫡

User Avatar @bucrob 1d

Not gonna read through all this but just make sure they get low flow, just enough to make their polyps sway gently. Also phosphates I normally keep high for them, they like a bit dirtier water as do most LPS. Alkalinity wise, stability is key, I’ve seen hammers thriving in a consistent 6.1dkh tank before. Light, they can do lower and higher light, minimum 75 par and a max of about 200-250 just make sure it’s moved up slowly

Sign in to join the conversation.

Download the ReefBay App
[email protected]
|
©ReefBay 2026

Join The Community

Create an account to contribute to the community

Or continue with
Sign in with Apple
Or continue with
Sign in with Apple

Prefer our mobile app?

QR Code

Scan to download the app

Download ReefBay

Scan the QR code with your phone to download the app

Download ReefBay QR Code

Available on iOS and Android