Why is my wall hammer coral not opening fully

Vinny
Vin
@Vinny · 2 weeks ago

URGENT HELP!! I have had one hammer die last week, didn’t think too much of it but now another wall hammer is looking dodgy like that one was before it died.

It’s not opening up fully and two parts are completely retracted and looks extremely unhappy. Please any and all suggestions for how to fix this issue are appreciated and valued

2 photos
20

Comments

Sign in to leave a comment

Check alk and salinity swings first.

I doubted salinity but I checked it and it was in range around 34ppt. Alk I can’t check yet but I will be checking it and my LFS ASAP.

Also did just do a water change and it’s looking a little better

It was alk at 5.8dKH

High nitrates and phosphate will do that. Check your MG, CA and KH make sure they are stable along side your Ph 8.1 to 8.3. If it’s lower, adding a CO2 will help increase through your skimmer. Happy Reefing

Oh ok I’m decently new to reefing and am a bit unsure I just know the big issues like BJD and salinity. I’m getting it checked tomorrow morning and need it sorted by Thursday cause I have a non cancelable 24k gold torch and don’t want any issues with that for sure. Thanks for your help and I’ll let you know what the issue was.

Best of luck, enjoy the process it will course correct soon enough. Less is more in this hobby we love.

Yeah I run low tech I have mostly biological filtration in both my tanks and don’t mess around with it much

Do you have media reactors running? Phosguard will help with high phosphates and nitrates can be controlled as well.

No I don’t as I have nanos

They have small media bags for nanos. I would definitely try it out

OHHHHH I do run activated carbon and I will get some phosguard also have a look at the comment I posted about the recession and tell me what you think

Comment image

Also I’ve noticed light tissue recession around the flesh band just now. Here’s a pic

I have just started dosing CVE+ on the recommend does for a softie/lps system

Great source to add. The way your corals are looking it looks like high nitrates and phosphate mate. Definitely test water parameters and ensure they are with in recommend ppm. PAR lighting is important, while some thrive on lower PARS other require more lighting so coral placement is extremely important so you don’t burn them out.

So I just got it tested the alk was only 5.8dKH so definitely gonna be that nitrates and phos were perfectly in range

What did your phosphates and nitrates read at. 5.8 is extremely low and put corals at risk. Specially SPS and some LPS corals

So the system is LPS and Softies only the only issue rn is the hammers. Nitrate was 17 and phos was 0.1

0.1 bit high 0.03 is preferred

It’s on the high end of the range. This system is 90% softies and the rest hammers so the higher phosphate isn’t horribly alarming it stable

Sign in to join the conversation.

Livestock in this post

©ReefBay 2026

Join The Community

Create an account to contribute to the community

Or continue with
Sign in with Apple
Or continue with
Sign in with Apple

Prefer our mobile app?

QR Code

Scan to download the app

Download ReefBay

Scan the QR code with your phone to download the app

Download ReefBay QR Code

Available on iOS and Android